CUSTOM CAKES & CATERING
Next day orders
Next-Day Pickup Menu This menu is available for next-day pickup only and features select items prepared in limited quantities. Items are offered in family sizes and set options only. No customizations or substitutions.
Cinnamon Rolls
treat yourself (or a few lucky others) to six of our signature soft & gooey cinnamon rolls, made fresh in-house at Sweet Indulgence. 👉 Choose your style: • One Flavor Only – Choose from: – Classic Cinnamon – Sweet Potato – Peach Cobbler
Cinnamon Rolls
treat yourself (or a few lucky others) to four or six of our signature soft & gooey cinnamon rolls, made fresh in-house at Sweet Indulgence.
4 pk clasic
$25
4 pk sticky bun
$25
4 pk sweet potato
$30
4 pk peach cobbler
$30
6 pk classic
$35
6 pk sticky bun (walnut/raisins)
$35
6 pk sweet potato
$35
6 pk peach cobbler
$35
6 pk multi (2ea flavor)
$40
1 dz classic (12pk)
$60
cinnamon roll topping
cream cheese icing 8oz
$5peach cobbler topping
$7glazed walnuts & raisins
$5Mini Cinnamon Rolls
Our famous cinnamon rolls, baked in a smaller portion catering-size that’s perfect for sharing at meetings, staff breakfasts, and events. Each roll is soft, gooey, and topped with our signature cream cheese icing.
8 pk minis
$24
8 pk sticky buns (walnut/raisins)
$24
12 pk minis
$34
cinnamon roll topping
cream cheese icing 8oz
$5peach cobbler topping
$7glazed walnuts & raisins
$51 Dozen Mini Cinnamon Rolls + Coffee Box
12 Classic mini catering-size cinnamon rolls with 1 Coffee Box (96 oz, ~12 cups) including cups, sugar, and creamers. Feeds ~12. Minimum 1 dozen.
$60
cinnamon roll topping
cream cheese icing 8oz
$5peach cobbler topping
$7glazed walnuts & raisins
$52 Dozen Mini Cinnamon Rolls + 2 Coffee Boxes
24 Classic mini catering-size cinnamon rolls with 2 Coffee Boxes (192 oz, ~24 cups). Feeds ~20–24.
$120
Banana Pudding
Banana Pudding (Best Seller) The pudding everyone talks about. Creamy, classic, and made fresh in-house daily. Available in individual, family size, and larger portions while supplies last.
Classic Banana Pudding
Our famous classic pudding is made with delicious light a creamy custard and then layered with fresh sliced bananas, nilla waffer crumble, and topped with sweet crisp nilla waffer cookies
quart 32oz
$25.00
small 8oz
$10
large 12oz
$12
pan (1/2 catering pan)
$55
Deluxe Banana Pudding
our Classic banana pudding with caramel drizzle, extra chessman cookie, and topped with our creamy dreamy whip cream
quart 32oz
$30
small 8oz
$12
large 12oz
$14
pan (1/2 catering pan)
$65
Strawberry Crunch
Creamy vanilla pudding layered with strawberry cake, fresh berries, strawberry glaze, and a buttery crunch topping. A fan favorite with serious flavor!
quart 32oz
$25
small 8oz
$10
large 12oz
$12
pan (1/2 catering pan)
$55
banana cheesecake biscoff pudding
Indulge in our decadent Banana Cheesecake Biscoff Pudding, featuring creamy vanilla pudding infused with chunks of banana cheesecake, topped with a generous sprinkling of Biscoff cookie crumble, and finished with a luscious cookie butter drizzle. It’s a delightful blend of flavors that will leave you craving more! prices may vary in store
quart 32oz
$25.00
small 8oz
$10
large 12oz
$12.00
extras
edible waffle cup
$3.00extra wafer cookies
$1.00extra chessman cookies
$1.50
Oreo Pudding
A cookies-and-cream dream—smooth Vanilla pudding layered with moist chocolate cake chunks, drizzled with chocolate, topped with Oreo crumble and a whole cookie. Rich, indulgent, and always a favorite.
quart 32oz
$25
small 8oz
$10
large 12oz
$12
pan (1/2 catering pan)
$55
